Perhaps you have seen something like this; if not, most of us have been in restaurants enough to imagine it:
A busy restaurant. The wait-staff ranges among the tables balancing trays carefully loaded with meals. Each waitress knows how to load and unload the tray to maintain balance and avert meals crashing to the floor. Among themselves they call this the ‘free-tray-loading system’.
A new assistant manager shows up. This new assistant manager has no experience working in a restaurant, has no knowledge of the actual operations of a restaurant, but he has eaten in many restaurants, has a Harvard law degree, and has the power (perhaps he’s the owner’s nephew) to improve things.
This new, bright, superior assistant manger sees something he does not like in the way some trays are loaded. Because of his education and high IQ, he knows he can make an improvement, so he begins fiddling with (“improving”, he says) how the plates are arranged as the waitresses and waiters pass. This continues for several days, as waiters cope with the rebalanced loads, and the assistant manager gains confidence in his expertise.
Up to this point, there hasn’t been a tray dropped in the restaurant for many years.
One day, after the assistant manager makes an adjustment, the waitress progresses 20 feet towards her table while struggling with the unbalanced tray, then drops the entire thing. Food and dishes crash to the floor, splattered patrons upset their own tables as they jerk in surprise, and the restaurant business comes to a halt – a major crisis.
The assistant manager could respond in one of two ways:
1) “Oops! I guess I better leave things to the people who know what they are doing.”
2) “This just shows that the wait staff doesn’t know how to load and handle trays on their own. The ‘free-tray-loading system’ has failed. I must step in and manage this.”
The Parable Explained
With Congress and the previous several Administrations ever more active in fiddling with how the experts ran the mortgage markets, fiddling by the Bush administration brought trays crashing to the floor, causing a crisis in the entire financial system.
Congress and the new Administration have solemnly given response number 2.
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Liberty vs. Freedom (2)
I try to use the word ‘liberty’ rather than ‘freedom’ and the term ‘at liberty’ rather than ‘free.’ Not because I don’t like ‘freedom’ and ‘free’, less because I don’t like the concepts behind them, but because ‘free’ has many meanings. Use of the more precise terms eliminates potential ambiguity in what I am saying and, more important, forces me to be clear about what I am thinking.
‘Free’ can mean things antithetical to liberty. People can be made free of sin, or free of the contradictions inherent to capitalism (per Marx) only by making them decidedly unfree in other ways. To be kept free of sin, somebody must prevent the people – by force and threat of violence – from doing those things some authority considers sinful.
Liberty can be extinguished in pursuit of freedom, depending on what is meant by ‘free’.
Origin and Definition
‘Liberty’ comes to us from the Latin ‘libertas’, itself a noun based on the Latin ‘liber’ meaning free. ‘Liber’, however, has not been adopted into modern English in any form I am aware of.
The American Heritage Dictionary (online at http://www.bartleby.com/61/1/L0150100.html) defines ‘liberty’ as :
1a. The condition of being free from restriction or control. b. The right and power to act, believe, or express oneself in a manner of one's own choosing. c. The condition of being physically and legally free from confinement, servitude, or forced labor. See synonyms at freedom. 2. Freedom from unjust or undue governmental control. 3. A right or immunity to engage in certain actions without control or interference: the liberties protected by the Bill of Rights. 4a. A breach or overstepping of propriety or social convention. Often used in the plural. b. A statement, attitude, or action not warranted by conditions or actualities: a historical novel that takes liberties with chronology. c. An unwarranted risk; a chance: took foolish liberties on the ski slopes. 5. A period, usually short, during which a sailor is authorized to go ashore.
The first three meanings refer to being unconstrained by human or state agencies. None of the definitions have anything to do with being immune to unpleasant conditions (hunger, fear), uncontaminated, available at no cost, or any of the other meanings of ‘free’ and ‘freedom’ that are not synonymous with ‘liberty’.
What I mean by ‘liberty’
Ludwig von Mises wrote:
‘This is what the modern concept of freedom means. Every adult is free to fashion his life according to its own plans. He is not forced to live according to the plan of a planning authority enforcing its unique plan by the police, i.e., the social apparatus of compulsion and coercion. What restricts the individual’s freedom is not other people’s violence or threat of violence, but the physiological structure of his body and the inescapable nature-given scarcity of the factors of production.’
– Ludwig von Mises, The Anti-Capitalist Mentality p. 3
In this passage, von Mises defines the ‘liberty’ meaning of ‘freedom’. I would simply substitute ‘liberty’ for ‘freedom’ and ‘at liberty’ for ‘free’ in the above passage.
Fredrich von Hayek defined freedom, or liberty as “independence of the arbitrary will of another”.
I accept the definitions given by Mises and Hayek. In my words, ‘liberty’ is “the condition of being not subject to the will of another person or institution under the threat or actuality of violence.” A person has liberty to the extent he is immune to violence, particularly legitimate violence. Liberty means being able to ignore the will of another without suffering violence to ones person, property, nor the suffering of violence by proxy: “do what I want or I’ll hurt your friend.”
The only constraints facing an individual in his or her pursuit of desires or implementation of a life plan are the realities of the physical world (which include the scarcity of desirable things), the limitations of his or her body and mind, and the requirement not to interfere with the liberty of anyone else. (Enforcement of this last limitation is why the state, with its monopoly on legitimate violence, is necessary for the realization of human liberty.)
This is merely a restatement of the American Heritage definitions 1&2 (above). Obviously, this is synonymous with the definition of ‘freedom’ commonly used in political contexts by Americans. Similarly, being ‘at liberty’ or ‘in the condition of having liberty’ is synonymous with ‘free’ as commonly used in the same context.
I prefer ‘liberty’ and ‘at liberty’ simply because there is less room for ambiguity, not because of any disagreement with the appropriate definitions of ‘freedom’ and ‘free’
‘Free’ can mean things antithetical to liberty. People can be made free of sin, or free of the contradictions inherent to capitalism (per Marx) only by making them decidedly unfree in other ways. To be kept free of sin, somebody must prevent the people – by force and threat of violence – from doing those things some authority considers sinful.
Liberty can be extinguished in pursuit of freedom, depending on what is meant by ‘free’.
Origin and Definition
‘Liberty’ comes to us from the Latin ‘libertas’, itself a noun based on the Latin ‘liber’ meaning free. ‘Liber’, however, has not been adopted into modern English in any form I am aware of.
The American Heritage Dictionary (online at http://www.bartleby.com/61/1/L0150100.html) defines ‘liberty’ as :
1a. The condition of being free from restriction or control. b. The right and power to act, believe, or express oneself in a manner of one's own choosing. c. The condition of being physically and legally free from confinement, servitude, or forced labor. See synonyms at freedom. 2. Freedom from unjust or undue governmental control. 3. A right or immunity to engage in certain actions without control or interference: the liberties protected by the Bill of Rights. 4a. A breach or overstepping of propriety or social convention. Often used in the plural. b. A statement, attitude, or action not warranted by conditions or actualities: a historical novel that takes liberties with chronology. c. An unwarranted risk; a chance: took foolish liberties on the ski slopes. 5. A period, usually short, during which a sailor is authorized to go ashore.
The first three meanings refer to being unconstrained by human or state agencies. None of the definitions have anything to do with being immune to unpleasant conditions (hunger, fear), uncontaminated, available at no cost, or any of the other meanings of ‘free’ and ‘freedom’ that are not synonymous with ‘liberty’.
What I mean by ‘liberty’
Ludwig von Mises wrote:
‘This is what the modern concept of freedom means. Every adult is free to fashion his life according to its own plans. He is not forced to live according to the plan of a planning authority enforcing its unique plan by the police, i.e., the social apparatus of compulsion and coercion. What restricts the individual’s freedom is not other people’s violence or threat of violence, but the physiological structure of his body and the inescapable nature-given scarcity of the factors of production.’
– Ludwig von Mises, The Anti-Capitalist Mentality p. 3
In this passage, von Mises defines the ‘liberty’ meaning of ‘freedom’. I would simply substitute ‘liberty’ for ‘freedom’ and ‘at liberty’ for ‘free’ in the above passage.
Fredrich von Hayek defined freedom, or liberty as “independence of the arbitrary will of another”.
I accept the definitions given by Mises and Hayek. In my words, ‘liberty’ is “the condition of being not subject to the will of another person or institution under the threat or actuality of violence.” A person has liberty to the extent he is immune to violence, particularly legitimate violence. Liberty means being able to ignore the will of another without suffering violence to ones person, property, nor the suffering of violence by proxy: “do what I want or I’ll hurt your friend.”
The only constraints facing an individual in his or her pursuit of desires or implementation of a life plan are the realities of the physical world (which include the scarcity of desirable things), the limitations of his or her body and mind, and the requirement not to interfere with the liberty of anyone else. (Enforcement of this last limitation is why the state, with its monopoly on legitimate violence, is necessary for the realization of human liberty.)
This is merely a restatement of the American Heritage definitions 1&2 (above). Obviously, this is synonymous with the definition of ‘freedom’ commonly used in political contexts by Americans. Similarly, being ‘at liberty’ or ‘in the condition of having liberty’ is synonymous with ‘free’ as commonly used in the same context.
I prefer ‘liberty’ and ‘at liberty’ simply because there is less room for ambiguity, not because of any disagreement with the appropriate definitions of ‘freedom’ and ‘free’
Ending Patriarchy by Exalting the State
A peculiarity dawned on me this morning: Progressive women don't want to be protected, guided, or cared for by a man in their lives. A good thing, IMO.
They want the State to do it. A bad thing, IMO.
Strange. Stand up for your rights, then surrender them to the government.
Maybe it's just about men, not female autonomy.
They want the State to do it. A bad thing, IMO.
Strange. Stand up for your rights, then surrender them to the government.
Maybe it's just about men, not female autonomy.
Conflicting Moral Traditions (1)
We are primates. Our branch of the Primate order, Simians, includes monkeys and apes, almost all of which live in communities commonly called “troops”. Orangutans are, I believe, the only Simians that live solitary, isolated lives.
Simians split off from other primates about 65 million years ago (about the time dinosaurs disappeared). Since almost all modern simians live communally in isolated troops, it’s a safe bet that our ancestors, all the way back until before apes split from the Old World monkeys 30-some million years ago, lived communally in troops. Being universal, communal living with the behaviors that go along with communal living must be instinctive to all apes. All apes (but the one species that evolved separatist instincts) including us.
Simians are smart. Pre-programmed robot-like behavior is inconsistent with the flexibility and wide range of behaviors exhibited by simians. Our actions can only be guided, not determined, by genetic instincts. Think about it: as humans our actions are guided primarily by our thoughts and emotions. Thoughts derive from cultural learning, but even our thoughts are intertwined with emotions. Our actions to obtain food are learned but are driven by our dislike of feeling hungry. Even our sexual drive is emotional, leading us to desire actions we can control. While the desire is instinctual, what we do about the desire, how we act, is under the control of our thoughts as well as other instinctual emotions (like the fear of being killed by her husband).
We evolved with instinctive emotions leading us to desire communal living and the behaviors necessary for the success of the community: altruism, affinity for others, loyalty to the troop, acceptance of leadership, sharing, submersion of the self to communal needs, and dedication to communal ends like finding food or shelter or protecting the troop from predators (and other troops).
Hmmm. Altruism. Affinity for others. Loyalty to the community. Submersion of the self. Acceptance of communal leadership. Sharing. Communal objectives taking precedence over personal objectives.
Sounds like… Socialism! And it is. Socialism is instinctive in humans in that our emotions favor the communitarian behaviors of Socialism over the individualistic behaviors of free-market Capitalism.
That is why I claim that Socialism is reactionary, anachronistic, a throwback to our past. But something we still, instinctively, find emotionally satisfying. Our instincts make us desire socialism.
Simians split off from other primates about 65 million years ago (about the time dinosaurs disappeared). Since almost all modern simians live communally in isolated troops, it’s a safe bet that our ancestors, all the way back until before apes split from the Old World monkeys 30-some million years ago, lived communally in troops. Being universal, communal living with the behaviors that go along with communal living must be instinctive to all apes. All apes (but the one species that evolved separatist instincts) including us.
Simians are smart. Pre-programmed robot-like behavior is inconsistent with the flexibility and wide range of behaviors exhibited by simians. Our actions can only be guided, not determined, by genetic instincts. Think about it: as humans our actions are guided primarily by our thoughts and emotions. Thoughts derive from cultural learning, but even our thoughts are intertwined with emotions. Our actions to obtain food are learned but are driven by our dislike of feeling hungry. Even our sexual drive is emotional, leading us to desire actions we can control. While the desire is instinctual, what we do about the desire, how we act, is under the control of our thoughts as well as other instinctual emotions (like the fear of being killed by her husband).
We evolved with instinctive emotions leading us to desire communal living and the behaviors necessary for the success of the community: altruism, affinity for others, loyalty to the troop, acceptance of leadership, sharing, submersion of the self to communal needs, and dedication to communal ends like finding food or shelter or protecting the troop from predators (and other troops).
Hmmm. Altruism. Affinity for others. Loyalty to the community. Submersion of the self. Acceptance of communal leadership. Sharing. Communal objectives taking precedence over personal objectives.
Sounds like… Socialism! And it is. Socialism is instinctive in humans in that our emotions favor the communitarian behaviors of Socialism over the individualistic behaviors of free-market Capitalism.
That is why I claim that Socialism is reactionary, anachronistic, a throwback to our past. But something we still, instinctively, find emotionally satisfying. Our instincts make us desire socialism.
Conflicting Moral Traditions (2)
Modern humans evolved from earlier species that had, for millions of years, existed as roving troops of, perhaps, a half-dozen to a dozen breeding-age females, their offspring, mates, juveniles, and non-breeding elders. They lived by gathering and hunting what they needed to survive.
No individual could survive for long without belonging to a troop, and a troop’s survival depended on all members working together to keep death rates below birth rates and out-migration balanced with in-migration as young adults moved to other troops in search of mates. Every individual depended on every other individual for survival and survival was precarious with times of plenty and times of dearth and famine. Life required the sharing of bounties as well as shortages and protecting other troop members from predators, even at the risk to oneself.
For 90% of our species existence, this was how all humans lived. Groups isolated in remote jungles still live this way and are occasionally discovered.
Troops comprised of individuals whose emotions moved them to support the troop community, individual who liked helping others, enjoyed sharing, working towards common aims, and protecting others would be more successful (and more likely to produce surviving offspring) than troops of individuals lacking these desires. Indeed, individuals lacking communal emotional drives would wander off, or be driven off, and not survive. Rugged individualism was a fatal strategy.
It would be a marvel if our instinctive emotions, developed over millions of years of evolution, were not those that supported the communal life of a small band or troop, the micro-cosmos (to use Hayek's term) of human society.
Socialism and communalism are instinctively attractive to humans. The morality of Socialism appeals to us and is more emotionally satisfying than the traditions and morality of free markets and the extended order of human interaction.
Unfortunately, communalism works only among small troops of familiars living on the edge of survival. Socialism has nowhere taken human prosperity to any higher level than barely surviving – poverty almost unknown today. Human wealth and security, along with the large populations we have achieved, appeared only after the traditions and standards of the micro-cosmos became modified and ultimately replaced by evolving traditions supporting human interactions for mutual benefit throughout the world outside the small band or troop - the macro-cosmos. Individuals doing things for the good of people they do not know (or even know exist) and receiving, in exchange, benefits from the efforts of distant others.
No individual could survive for long without belonging to a troop, and a troop’s survival depended on all members working together to keep death rates below birth rates and out-migration balanced with in-migration as young adults moved to other troops in search of mates. Every individual depended on every other individual for survival and survival was precarious with times of plenty and times of dearth and famine. Life required the sharing of bounties as well as shortages and protecting other troop members from predators, even at the risk to oneself.
For 90% of our species existence, this was how all humans lived. Groups isolated in remote jungles still live this way and are occasionally discovered.
Troops comprised of individuals whose emotions moved them to support the troop community, individual who liked helping others, enjoyed sharing, working towards common aims, and protecting others would be more successful (and more likely to produce surviving offspring) than troops of individuals lacking these desires. Indeed, individuals lacking communal emotional drives would wander off, or be driven off, and not survive. Rugged individualism was a fatal strategy.
It would be a marvel if our instinctive emotions, developed over millions of years of evolution, were not those that supported the communal life of a small band or troop, the micro-cosmos (to use Hayek's term) of human society.
Socialism and communalism are instinctively attractive to humans. The morality of Socialism appeals to us and is more emotionally satisfying than the traditions and morality of free markets and the extended order of human interaction.
Unfortunately, communalism works only among small troops of familiars living on the edge of survival. Socialism has nowhere taken human prosperity to any higher level than barely surviving – poverty almost unknown today. Human wealth and security, along with the large populations we have achieved, appeared only after the traditions and standards of the micro-cosmos became modified and ultimately replaced by evolving traditions supporting human interactions for mutual benefit throughout the world outside the small band or troop - the macro-cosmos. Individuals doing things for the good of people they do not know (or even know exist) and receiving, in exchange, benefits from the efforts of distant others.
Conflicting Moral Traditions (3)
Morality and Traditions of the Micro Order
Hunter-gatherer societies with their communal moral traditions – altruism, submersion of the self, accepting and working toward communal aims, and acceptance of personal risk for the good of the troop – enabled modern humans to survive and our population to expand to all continents but Antarctica. These instinctive moral traditions, which can be called the behavioral traditions of the micro order (the system of interactions among members of a troop), seem to have been the sole mode of social organization for perhaps 90% of our species’ existence.
But small-group socialism has its drawbacks. Related troops familiar with each other get along as part of a larger “tribe” but an unknown group of people was any troop’s most dangerous enemy. Though an individual would be helpless, a dozen or so adults could deal with almost any predator - big cats, bears, even a pack of wolves – but an unknown troop of humans might have the wherewithal to annihilate the entire troop. Other humans would be as intelligent and as organized as the defenders.
It is likely that xenophobia is instinctive.
Consider: when Europeans finally found the Americas, there were people living at the bottom of South America, Tierra del Fuego, a miserable place to eke out a living, 15,000 miles from where people migrated across the Bering Sea. The Yaghan people evidently made the trip in about 5,000 years. Certainly they didn’t settle there because they liked the view: they moved there to escape attacks by other tribes further north.
Limited Applicability
The instinctive morality of the micro order, the socialism of the isolated troop, depend on all individuals being familiar with each other and each being assured that everyone else in the troop abides by the same morality.
Though necessary for survival in small groups of hunter-gatherers, the instinctive emotions don’t work for an extended range of interactions. We cannot be altruistic towards people we don’t know exist. We cannot unselfishly do things for the benefit of folks we’ve never met. We can’t pursue common ends with distant people without surrendering to a dictatorial power.
Successful interaction for mutual benefit with distant or unknown people (trade) depends on traditions and morality different from those of the micro order.
Trade enabled the feeding of more people. Trade moved useful items – e.g., flints, sinews for bow strings, hides and furs, foodstuffs – moved from places of abundance to people who could not find these things locally. People could spend more time gathering food rather than searching for needed items or travelling to where the items were available. A troop didn’t need to travel many miles to a quarry to get flint for tools and spear points, the flint would come to them.
Trade made fixed settlements possible and enabled the development and spread of agriculture.
Changes to the Old Instinctive Morality
To be widespread and successful, trade needs changes to the instinctive morality and traditions of small-group socialism that had served humans and our predecessors for millions of years.
Hunter-gatherer societies with their communal moral traditions – altruism, submersion of the self, accepting and working toward communal aims, and acceptance of personal risk for the good of the troop – enabled modern humans to survive and our population to expand to all continents but Antarctica. These instinctive moral traditions, which can be called the behavioral traditions of the micro order (the system of interactions among members of a troop), seem to have been the sole mode of social organization for perhaps 90% of our species’ existence.
But small-group socialism has its drawbacks. Related troops familiar with each other get along as part of a larger “tribe” but an unknown group of people was any troop’s most dangerous enemy. Though an individual would be helpless, a dozen or so adults could deal with almost any predator - big cats, bears, even a pack of wolves – but an unknown troop of humans might have the wherewithal to annihilate the entire troop. Other humans would be as intelligent and as organized as the defenders.
It is likely that xenophobia is instinctive.
Consider: when Europeans finally found the Americas, there were people living at the bottom of South America, Tierra del Fuego, a miserable place to eke out a living, 15,000 miles from where people migrated across the Bering Sea. The Yaghan people evidently made the trip in about 5,000 years. Certainly they didn’t settle there because they liked the view: they moved there to escape attacks by other tribes further north.
Limited Applicability
The instinctive morality of the micro order, the socialism of the isolated troop, depend on all individuals being familiar with each other and each being assured that everyone else in the troop abides by the same morality.
Though necessary for survival in small groups of hunter-gatherers, the instinctive emotions don’t work for an extended range of interactions. We cannot be altruistic towards people we don’t know exist. We cannot unselfishly do things for the benefit of folks we’ve never met. We can’t pursue common ends with distant people without surrendering to a dictatorial power.
Successful interaction for mutual benefit with distant or unknown people (trade) depends on traditions and morality different from those of the micro order.
Trade enabled the feeding of more people. Trade moved useful items – e.g., flints, sinews for bow strings, hides and furs, foodstuffs – moved from places of abundance to people who could not find these things locally. People could spend more time gathering food rather than searching for needed items or travelling to where the items were available. A troop didn’t need to travel many miles to a quarry to get flint for tools and spear points, the flint would come to them.
Trade made fixed settlements possible and enabled the development and spread of agriculture.
Changes to the Old Instinctive Morality
To be widespread and successful, trade needs changes to the instinctive morality and traditions of small-group socialism that had served humans and our predecessors for millions of years.
Conflicting Moral Traditions (4)
Morality and Traditions of the Macro-Cosmos Support Larger Populations
The First Change: Private (or Several) Property Replaces Common Property
Efficient trade depends on individual, or private, property. Long distance trade cannot be conducted by entire communities. People specialized: some traded, some gathered food or made tools, and all were made better off by trading the products of their efforts and talents.
If a troop loads up a trader with local flints to trade with the mountain people for furs they wanted assurances that the trader wouldn’t, at the first sign of a hungry wolf, ditch the flints and hustle back to the troop for communal protection and communal food. Solution: sell the flints to the trader by demanding from him things of value before he left. The flints became the trader’s property, his private property, not goods held in common. On his return with furs, his furs obtained in trade with the mountain people, the trader would trade furs for more flints: his flints, not the troops common flints.
Second Change: Individual Judgment Replaces Communal Judgment
Trade depends on individual judgment and individual knowledge, not the communal wisdom of the troop. To the extent that a trader was on his own (or with a few colleagues) it was up to the trader to decide how many flints to exchange for how many furs and, on the other end, how many furs to exchange for how many flints. The trader had to know where to locate the people with the best furs, how to communicate with them, and how to assure them he was not a threat. And not a cheat: you can’t trade with someone after you’ve cheated him.
Trade depends on the trader working towards his own ends using his own judgment, not towards communal aims based on communal judgment.
Third Change: Exchange for Mutual Benefit Replaces Altruistic Giving
Trade depends on voluntary exchange for mutual benefit, not on the altruistic sharing that cements relationships and sustains a communal group. The trader expects to make a profit on each exchange and learns that this is possible only if those he is exchanging with also make a profit – improve their circumstances.
Fourth Change: Greater Specialization
Trading enables individuals to make, find, or capture something not because the troop (or someone in the troop) needed or wanted it but because it could be traded for something the individual wanted. Trade withing the troop enabled the specialist to eat without hunting or gathering food. Other specialists would gather food, perhaps using tools made by the specialist to increase their productivity. Because not everyone had to spend most of his time looking for food, the society could support more people who could live longer lives.
Now, One Need Not Be "Good" to Provide Benefits for Others
These changes are related to, or encouraged, individualism rather than communalism. Even selfish people contributed to the well being of others as they could gain for themselves only by providing gain for others. The new morality and its supporting traditions enabled the creation of an extended order (extended beyond the local troop or those few troops nearby) of voluntary interaction of people working for the benefit of, and receiving benefits from, those distant and unknown. This extended order operating in the macro-cosmos depended on the evolution of morals and traditions quite different from the instinctive morality that guided the communalism of the micro-cosmos.
The First Change: Private (or Several) Property Replaces Common Property
Efficient trade depends on individual, or private, property. Long distance trade cannot be conducted by entire communities. People specialized: some traded, some gathered food or made tools, and all were made better off by trading the products of their efforts and talents.
If a troop loads up a trader with local flints to trade with the mountain people for furs they wanted assurances that the trader wouldn’t, at the first sign of a hungry wolf, ditch the flints and hustle back to the troop for communal protection and communal food. Solution: sell the flints to the trader by demanding from him things of value before he left. The flints became the trader’s property, his private property, not goods held in common. On his return with furs, his furs obtained in trade with the mountain people, the trader would trade furs for more flints: his flints, not the troops common flints.
Second Change: Individual Judgment Replaces Communal Judgment
Trade depends on individual judgment and individual knowledge, not the communal wisdom of the troop. To the extent that a trader was on his own (or with a few colleagues) it was up to the trader to decide how many flints to exchange for how many furs and, on the other end, how many furs to exchange for how many flints. The trader had to know where to locate the people with the best furs, how to communicate with them, and how to assure them he was not a threat. And not a cheat: you can’t trade with someone after you’ve cheated him.
Trade depends on the trader working towards his own ends using his own judgment, not towards communal aims based on communal judgment.
Third Change: Exchange for Mutual Benefit Replaces Altruistic Giving
Trade depends on voluntary exchange for mutual benefit, not on the altruistic sharing that cements relationships and sustains a communal group. The trader expects to make a profit on each exchange and learns that this is possible only if those he is exchanging with also make a profit – improve their circumstances.
Fourth Change: Greater Specialization
Trading enables individuals to make, find, or capture something not because the troop (or someone in the troop) needed or wanted it but because it could be traded for something the individual wanted. Trade withing the troop enabled the specialist to eat without hunting or gathering food. Other specialists would gather food, perhaps using tools made by the specialist to increase their productivity. Because not everyone had to spend most of his time looking for food, the society could support more people who could live longer lives.
Now, One Need Not Be "Good" to Provide Benefits for Others
These changes are related to, or encouraged, individualism rather than communalism. Even selfish people contributed to the well being of others as they could gain for themselves only by providing gain for others. The new morality and its supporting traditions enabled the creation of an extended order (extended beyond the local troop or those few troops nearby) of voluntary interaction of people working for the benefit of, and receiving benefits from, those distant and unknown. This extended order operating in the macro-cosmos depended on the evolution of morals and traditions quite different from the instinctive morality that guided the communalism of the micro-cosmos.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
